Fat and Not Afraid

Respect and love are for EVERY body.

header photo

Lose Weight or Lose Your Welfare

January 21, 2013

Why is it that some of the most disturbing stories I read about the treatment of fat people and their families comes out of the U.K? I'm sure it has something to do with them being a small island nation and purposely isolated for so much of history. In any case, while browsing through the latest http://www2.macleans.ca/ (January 21st edition, page 32) I found a story titled "Fat and On Welfare? Look Out". Look out indeed! A proposal from the Local Government Information Unit of Westminister would have fat people in London lose money on their benefit payments depending on how often they go to the gym.

Thankfully the idea has drawn nothing but criticism from doctors, but oddly enough this hasn't daunted the Information Unit in the slightest. They say it's time to get 'radical' on the obesity problem since doctors haven't been able to solve it. Um, I don't think it gets much more radical than pumping your own stomach or having surgery to rearrange and mutilate your digestive system. That's where we're at right now in the War on Obesity Fat People. That this Unit wants to save money is absolutely clear; it's not about encouraging healthy habits, this is about pinching pennies and doing what they feel is best for the bottom line. Disgusting. (You can see the full proposal HERE)

Now, juxtapose that Maclean's story with this one from the Mirror, a UK publication: Starving children surviving on just a jam sandwich a day. From the Mirror-"These shocking revelations lay bare the plight of thousands of families as children as young as four are found to be malnourished.

The Sunday Mirror has exposed the shocking statistics of Food Bank Britain, where 250,000 people used the charity-run food depots last year.

The Trussell Trust now has more than 250 food banks nationwide and today we talk to people who have had to turn to them as a last resort."

Are these families going to lose their benefits if one of the kids or parents is fat, and doesn't go to the gym as the doctor prescribed? Who's going to pay for the family to go and do this exercise, or pay for the sitter to watch the kids while mom and/or dad go?

And what happens when they go to gym and DON'T lose weight? Are they still going to lose benefits? Because it's been documented that exercise doesn't help much when it comes to losing weight. It can help you get healthier and more fit, but it's not going to make you thin (unless, of course, you're starving yourself while exercising for hours a day).

My thought exactly, JeninCanada. Even if fat is lost, if you're adding muscle, you may end up gaining weight, since a cubic inch of muscle weighs more than a cubic inch of fat. So losing inches of fat, while replacing it with smaller, denser muscle could have you either staying the same weight, or even gaining weight while losing inches of size (if that makes sense).



Comment

Comments for this post have been disabled.

Full Disclosure

Every once in a very great while there may be a post which contains a link to a product or service for which I've been paid to promote or have recieved for review purposes. I Blog With Integrity so you'll know which is which.